jump to navigation

Flow My Tears, The Robber Said in Jean-Luc Godard’s Band of Outsiders (1964) December 20, 2007

Posted by Richard Bolisay in European Films, French Spring, Literature.

Original Title: Bande à part
Written and directed by Jean-Luc Godard
Cast: Anna Karina, Sami Frey, Claude Brasseur
Based on Dolores Hitchens’ Fools’ Gold

Children looking for summaries — don’t go here. If you are really serious about cinema, forget about plot narratives. Forget about coherence and linearity. Forget about beauty and depth. Forget about Roger Ebert and Jonathan Rosenbaum. Forget about reviews and ratings. Forget even about writing. Forget everything — and that’s the reason why Godard continues to fascinate me, for he relentlessly avoids these things — he ranks among the Greek and Roman gods; he is peerless, no one can ever surpass him — he has built a world, a galaxy of works that has changed a landscape — that inimitable greatness that is very much felt a million frames per second. And considering the films he made in the sixties — the atomic bomb he dropped in the history of cinema — he surely has lived up to his name as the landmark filmmaker of the 20th century.

Band of Outsiders was shot after Contempt, Godard’s venture to the CinemaScope which fairly doubles the omnipresent enigma of his style, and surprisingly, he still hasn’t left the mark of his black-and-white effrontery — the audacity which catapulted his name to criticism — with a little help from French New Wave’s most revered cinematographer, Raoul Coutard. Well, ‘little’ here speaks of a grand scale that no pair has ever achieved before, with the possible exception of Ingmar Bergman and Sven Nykvist or, to satisfy my personal pleasure, Wong Kar-wai and Chris Doyle.

In A Woman is A Woman, Alphaville, Pierrot le fou, and My Life to Live, Godard has clearly showed his affection to Anna Karina. He is at the peak of his career, with groundbreaking films that defined a generation, and she is behind him every step of the way, even in real life, as his muse, as his dauntless woman of veneration — as seen in Agnes Varda’s Les Fiancés du Pont Mac Donald. Their pair is unmistakably full of vigor, much like Antonioni and Vitti’s collaboration is full of angst, and indeed the films they made together reflect the grueling ball of energy and passion they had then. But with Band of Outsiders, which hints a close reference to Jules and Jim — but I suppose everyone who has seen both films would agree that they are handled very differently, as if Godard and Truffaut have taken the same material and come up with works which are strikingly beautiful in their own way, a sense of uniqueness that only filmmakers like them could achieve — depicts more of a masterly partnership between Godard and Coutard, and in saying that this film might be the most accessible film he has made owes a lot to Coutard’s unwavering devotion to non-conformity, endlessly thinking of ways to shoot differently, and a genius for having made a name for himself apart from his directors.

It is difficult to discuss a film by Godard without relating it to his other works. Thus if one tries to compare Band of Outsiders with Pierrot le fou or Contempt, it certainly makes sense to claim that this film is better than the two, or just one film stands out among the three. That proves Pauline Kael’s assertion that “it is possible to hate half or two-thirds of what Godard does — or find it incomprehensible — and still be shattered by his brilliance.” And basing it on texture, Band of Outsiders is layered with countless allusions to literature and cinema, from Shakespeare to Kafka, from Billy the Kid to Loopy de Loop, from T. S. Eliot to Rimbaud, from Chaplin’s Immigrant to Demy’s Umbrellas of Cherbourg, not to mention a famous ad slogan “Bravo, Mr. Segalot. That’s real furniture!,” and an overflow of homage that only seems to work at his advantage — its entirety feels like a book of knowledge, and Godard eagerly opens the book for us, and we hear him speak, we hear his words of enlightenment and disarray, we listen to his truths and lies, we listen to his phrases of hope and discouragement — and we lend our ears like someone listening to a long-awaited Messiah — in a stream of eloquence.

This is the coolest Godard I’ve seen so far — cooler than Breathless, cooler than Masculine Feminine, cooler than In Praise of Love, which isn’t cool at all — cooler than the snow-capped Fuji, cooler than a red dress, cooler than Tarantino, and cooler than a bunch of thugs butchering each other. The Madison sequence and the world-breaking nine-minute visit inside the Louvre are stupefying — such magical moments full of vibe and energy — and if ever you accuse me of exaggerating then see for yourself. For Godard has not only broken the fourth wall, he smashes all walls; if you can imagine how the Colorado River carves the Grand Canyon for centuries, that’s how I see him — better not miss this quintessential vintage from the world’s greatest living director, and run for your life. * * * *



1. dodo dayao - December 21, 2007

Beautiful, chard. Band of Outsiders isn’t exactly Godard’s bravest or even best film but it’s the Godard closest to my heart, the one I can watch forever, the one that makes me feel butterflies in my belly every time I put it on. Gulo ba? :)

2. lilokpelikula - December 24, 2007

Thanks, do :D haha i feel the same way too. truly — it is not the best Godard but certainly it is one of his “more comprehensible” works — fun, fun, fun. The Criterion Collection from our local Cinematheque has loads of features, and I love it! Haha, I still can’t move on with Pierrot le fou though.

3. dodo dayao - December 27, 2007

Pierrot le Fou has lots of terrific lines, not least of which was the one Samuel Fuller delivered. I liked it but I only became friends with it once I saw it in the context of Godard’s bloody valentine to his divorce with Anna Karina. Still, I don’t love it as much as I love Bande A Part or even A Bout De Souffle, for that matter. Astig nga ang Criterion niyan! :)

Belated Merry Merry pala, chard! At advanced Happy 2008! :)

4. lilokpelikula - December 28, 2007

haha baka adik lang ako — sobrang naiinspire ako nung dynamite ending e. ansarap gawin. hehe. si godard na siguro ang pinakaastig na direktor na makikilala ko — maski anung gawa niya papanuorin ko. sabi ni anna karina dun sa interview, sa lahat ng mga pinupuntahan nilang bansa, iba-iba yung mga pelikula ni godard na gusto ng mga tao. sa japan — pierrot, sa europe — breathless, sa iba — band of outsiders. nakakatuwa lang. the way cinema transcends perception. bilang mahilig tayo sa science fiction, tingin ko hindi rin malayo na nagustuhan mo ang alphaville di ba? anganda nun. wala lang.

maligayang pasko at manigong bagong taon din sa’yo, do! toast tayo diyan! :D

5. dodo dayao - December 28, 2007

Alphaville astig. Pool sequence – – -bautiful. Astig din yung process – – -inanguluhan lang ang medyo kaibang building sa paris for its futristic look. Napakasimple di ba? Napaka-punk. Iniidolo-idolo ko tong si Godard for being the embodiment of street filmmaking, hardcore na indie. Alphaville reminds me of Grant Morrison, too, in some weird way, or maybe not so weird. Godard would be perfect for an Invisibles movie, I think. Or maybe not. Hehe.

Cheers, chard! :)

6. lilokpelikula - December 29, 2007

oo yung pool — sobrang eerie, nakakabingi lahat. JLA lang yung natatandaan kong nabasa kay morrison — at syempre pag bata ka, gusto mo talaga lahat kahit hindi mo masyadong matandaan yung mga detalye — gusto ko pa makabasa sa kanya kaso aminin natin ang mamahal ng komiks. hehe. gagawa kaya si Godard ng pelikula base sa komiks — tama, yan ang kaabang-abang! pero mukhang malabo nga — in our dreams perhaps. :D

7. dodo dayao - December 29, 2007

Magdownload ka ng CDisplay, chard. Freeware yan. Pwede kitang i-email ng mga digital comics pagkatapos. Morrison, Moore, etc. Sanayang magbasa ng komiks sa PC screen pero sa laki ng tipid, sulit na sulit na. Hehe. ;)

8. lilokpelikula - December 29, 2007

Sige idownload ko yan! Haha medyo utal ako sa technology kaya di ako gamay sa mga ganyang bagay. Salamat, do :D Magandang impluwensya yan. Hehe.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: